Fanatsy Football Trade????

Question

I give up Peyton Manning, Andre Johnson, Brandon Marshall, and Rob Bironas

I get Ben Roethlisberger, Terrell Owens, Santonio Holmes, and Stephen Gostkowski

Rate this trade, as I have already traded, I just want to know what you people think about it.

Answer 1

you did allright- I would have done it !

Answer 2

Peyton vs. Ben.  Peyton easily wins.  He will have a bounce back year.

T.O. vs Andre.  T.O. barely wins if Andre never gets hurt

Marshall vs. Holmes.  Tie.  It depends if you had bad backup wide recievers.  If you did, good.

Kickers don't matter that much to make a huge difference

Overall:  You did ok.  but you did better than him

Answer 3

The quarterback is a downgrade, but both WRs are an upgrade. Kickers usually don't make much difference, and it's all pretty random.

but a big rule in fantasy is that you shouldn't have more than 2 players on the same team as a starter. As long as you don't have any other Steelers starting for you, this should be a good trade.

Answer 4

7/10