Fantasy Football Trade Help...?

Question

Is this a fair deal Roy Williams and Tenn. Defense for Clinton Portis?

I have Clinton Portis and a friend of mine has proposed this trade because he is a big redskins fan and I am a Titans fan. My other runningbacks are Willis Mcgahee, Brandon Jacobs, Ahman green, and Kevin Smith.

Should I accept this offer?

Answer 1

No.

Martz left DET and they are looking to run a lot more this year and if Calvin Johnson stays healthy, I don't see Roy getting huge numbers.

As far as team D goes, you should be able to find a comparable one off the waiver wire once the season starts. Teams like MIN were not rated in the top 10 pre season last year and even DET ended up as a top 10 in fantasy points.

Even though it's a two for one trade, you still have to look and see who you would have to drop on your team to make this deal work. So packaging Portis with almost anybody else on your team to make this trade seems like you would be on the losing end.

Answer 2

Not even close,  RB is by far the most important position in fantasy football.  Get more in return, I would consider getting another RB if you trade Portis even though you have 3 good RBs in Willis Mcgahee, Brandon Jacobs, and Ahman green.

Answer 3

No. Clinton Portis is a really good RB which is hard to get. Don't do it.