Fantasy trade? need Opinion?

Question

who gets the better of these 2 deals

Victor Martinez

Jimmy Rollins

for

Jose Reyes

Eric Byrnes

and

Carlos Pena

for

Kosuke Foukudome

Answer 1

I would take the reyes side. He is a consistant SB and run producer... he also has decent pop in his bat... If you are on the reyes side I would try to get someone other than byrnes.... he might be good second half but he is historically bad in the second half in his career. and Pena I guess.... If you need HR

Answer 2

i would take victor martinez and jimmy rollins. jose reyes is only known for stolen base, while jimmy rollins can do well in almost every hitting category. victor martinez doesn't have the RBI numbers this year, but his average is not bad. he'll do better. byrnes is still on the DL.

for the second trade, it can go either way. pena can explode and give you tons of HRs and RBIs. fukudome will always have a good average while throwing in some runs. fukudome is the more consistent one, so at this point, i would take fukudome.

Answer 3

I would take VMartinez/Rollins because Victor has the potential to have an unbelievable 2nd half of season and Byrnes is struggling after a "break out" season.

Pena or Fukudome all depends on your fantasy needs.... Hr's or AVG/R's.

Answer 4

v mart and rollins only becasue it is basicallly 2 for 1 the way brynes sucks now

Answer 5

Guy who gets Reyes wins.

Guy who gets Fokudome wins.

Answer 6

V-Mart and Rollins better

Carlos Pena better

Answer 7

Well it depends on who your backup Catcher is and also Reyes is starting to get on aa hot streak. So no.

Answer 8

jose reyes gets the better deal on the first trade but if you need batting average on the 2nd trade go with fukudome but if u need power take pena