Girlfriend Advise fast reply please D:?

Question

(possibly confusing) Ive dated this girl off and on for about a month weve mutually broken up four times but cant seem to stay away from each other. I got back together with her last time but was told that another girl thinks im cute (i know this is very shallow but ive been waiting for a girl like her [athletic and fun] for a long time) So i broke up with girl 1 in hopes to get with girl 2. right now i could go either way the only things stopping my choice are Girl 1- none of my friends like her and say i could do better Girl 2-Shes a freshman and im a senior.

I like to say girl 1 makes me happy only at times but even when i "hate her" all i can do is want her. while girl 2 is just what im lookin for even my friends agree. P.S.(i dont care about a sexual part in either relationship)

Answer 1

if uve dated for about a month and broken up about 4 times, then its not right. move on. i dated someone for 10 months on/off and we only broke up 3 times. it seems like u both breakup once a week. thats ridiculous and un-called for. shes playing with you and when you take her back, she knows she has you in the palm of your hands. ignore her. completely stop talking to her and everything will fall into place, no matter what.  

Answer 2

OMG!  Why are you trippin' on girlz?!?  It's your senior year!!!  Besides college girls are waaaayyyyy more fun ;)

Answer 3

Well it sounds like u have true fellings for girl 1. Also if things dont work out with girl one, then freshman r always looking for an older guy to date.

Answer 4

you dont have real feelings for each other. only emotional.  it has to end sooner or later.

Answer 5

well you shouldnt let other people get in the way from liking someone.

but from what your saying about girl 1... it seems like theyre could be love and what your saying about girl 2 seems more like a temporary thing .. if you know what i mean?

Answer 6

Go with girl number 2, if you have broke up 4 times in the first month, with girl # 1, then something is wrong, who wants to spend all their time breaking up and getting back together? I could see it if it has been years, but... a month?

Answer 7

i say girl one, haha im in her position right now, kinda, sorta, maybe not. umm keep talking to girl 2 on a friend level get to know her and still be with 1

Answer 8

oviously it isnt guna work with u and girl one..

if it didnt work the first time it wasnt ment to be..

and dont redate exs in highschool..

Answer 9

go with what ever makes u happier. dont matter what ur friends think. they aint dating her u are