HUGH trade?

Question

I get

Darren Mcfadden

Randy Moss

I give up

Ryan Grant

Reggie Wayne

My RBs are Westbrook, Grant, and Willie Parker

my WRs Wayne, Roy Williams, Joey Galloway, and Cotchery

Answer 1

good trade.

Answer 2

keep ryan grant and reggie wayne. mcfadden is a rookie, and we don't know if he will even get most of the carries. reggie wayne is very consistent because peyton manning gets him the ball. ryan grant is the safer running back to go with.

Answer 3

DONT DO IT.

Mcfadden is a rookie so who knows what he will get for you.

I can promise you Reggie Wayne can TIE what Moss will do if not beat.

HOPE I HELPED

=D

Answer 4

Don't do it. Grant is better than Mcfadden based on rookie status. Grant is also on a better team than Mcfadden. Randy Moss is better than Wayne yes, but Moss will not have a year like last. His stats will take a dive of course and Wayne will be just as good as Moss this year.

Answer 5

idk mcfadden is a rookie and you dont no how he will do grant is good

so its pretty even because moss and wayne are both very good so i would sya its a pretty good trade

Answer 6

Well, here are some numbers to consider in overall rankings, in standard (non PPR) format:

D-Dawg - #45

Moss - #8

Grant - #15

Wayne - #13

What this means is that you take all the risk in the deal, and on paper, at least according to footballguys.com's rankings, you are overpaying.

McFadden has 0 NFL carries.

McFadden still has Fargas, Jordan, and Bush pushing for carries.

Jamarcus Russell is essentially a rookie QB.

I'm not sold on Ryan Grant, especially with Favre gone but I think he's the safer of the choices.

The choice is yours, but on paper your trading partner is putting all the risk on you and overcharging for Moss.