Have you seen this one yet?

Question

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDd2I8fr06Y&feature=related

Comments? Criticisms? I for one am a skeptic.

Answer 1

I'm wondering why there just "happened" to be a camera there at that time....following it. Hmmmm

Answer 2

I have not seen that. The field of focus seems a little off to me. Also, if someone's going to go through all the trouble of making a video like that, they need to put in the effort to make the ship disappear into the sky. Honestly, if anyone recoded something like that in real life, they wouldn't turn the camera off after 18 seconds.

Other than that, I thought it was pretty cool.

Answer 3

Having worked in publishing, I've seen lotsa things. This is really pretty good, but it is just a computer-simulated event with good sound and the manipulation of an overlaid sine wave.

The people at the beginning on the ground seem to have disproportionately-small heads.

The shadows on the buildings don't match up.

Very convincing, but the shape of the craft is built from prefabricated objects in the 3D Studio Max library. The object in front of it (what I'll call the "parking drone") also seems to be from the 3D Studio library, and appears from nowhere at 3 seconds in.

Fake, but a fairly nice one! This person might want to pursue a career in Hollywood!

Answer 4

It's a hoax.

It is a computer generated simulation.

If that was real, don't you think it would have been all over the news around the world, and still the talk of the century?

Answer 5

the people walking down the street at the beginning don't even notice.the shadowing of the craft is all wrong.definitely a fake