Is this a good baseball trade?

Question

CC Sabathia, Prince Fielder, and Miguel Tejada for Chase Utley and Jimmy Rollins.

I have Jerred Weaver, Roy Oswalt, Tim Hudson, Josh Johnson, Chris Carpenter, Ubaldo Jimenez and CC Sabathia as my rotation right now. My first basemen include James Loney and Prince Fielder, Second Base is Brian Roberts, Shortstop is JJ Hardy and Miguel Tejada.

Is this a good trade??

Thanks

Answer 1

No

You are giving up way too much.  Utley is cold right now.  Hudson is out for the year.  Carpenter is iffy when he comes back.  Oswalt has been up and down, not dominate.  Keep CC, you need him in your rotation right now.  jimenez has been hot so you need him with CC.  

In my opinion, you are giving up too much

Answer 2

NO WAAAAY

Dude CC Sabathia is at the top of his game right now and I would give up Prince Fielder (I have him too). Prince has done really good in the past couple days.