Is this a good fantasy trade?

Question

I give up:

Edgerrin James

Roddy White

I Get:

Julius Jones

Marques Colston

my rbs are grant, james, taylor, kevin smith

my wrs are moss burress white

Am I getting the better of this trade?

Answer 1

It all depends on your format....If you Have to start 3 Wide Receivers, then it looks like a great trade, I expect big things from Colston this year.  Edgerrin James is overvalued and Jones will probably end up with more TD's than Edge in the long haul and if this is a PPR league, then this is a no-brainer, especially considering that either Redman or Ryan will be throwing to Roddy, both who aren't very appealing.

Answer 2

Yeah, I'd definitely say so.

Answer 3

Edge is old... and forget Roddy White.. hes good but Marques Colston will outscore both of those guys combined.  Julius Jones is the clear #1 RB so he is a good pickup as well.. Take that trade all day.

Answer 4

well lets see

this is what i always do

edgerrin James < Julius Jones

Roddy White    < Marques Colston

well you have great running backs and wr and you are getting better but not alot better but its still better

Answer 5

yes

Answer 6

you are getting a great steal in marques colston.........he's gonna have an incredible year with drew brees; however im weary about julius jones because i don't think he's gonna get the same number of hand-offs he used to (especially being behind shaun alexander now)

but luckily you are giving up roddy white who is not gonna be all that impressive this year and although edgerrin james is good he's not gonna be winning you games (plus grant is a solid rb)

overall i say u got the advantage