Is this a good trade????

Question

I get: miguel cabrera,brian mccan,rich harden,miguel tejada,and brian roberts.

I give: garret atkins,geovany soto,hanley ramirez,and jake peavy

Answer 1

Soto is on fire and Hanley is awesome so I will not make that trade b/c Brian Mccan is not putting up the numbers like Soto, but Harden might shine in Cubbyland, so if in need for pitching maybe but remember Soto is doing well and will consistently produce and Hanley is awesome!

Answer 2

It is hard since your giving up hanley but your getting better players than your giving accecpt the trade and you will come in 1st or 2nd in your league

Answer 3

As much as I would hate to give up Hanley, I think you would get more in return, especially considering that Cabrera should heat up. Mccann is probably the best catcher this year, Harden went to a winning team, and roberts will steal a ton of bases. I guess do it, but if you could sub someone else in for Hanley I would.