LT or Adrian Peterson? fantsay question?

Question

who would u take first?

Answer 1

LT is a proven fantasy power.  Peterson is good but I would worry about injury.

Answer 2

agree LT...

if you are looking for another league...check out Yahoo free public ID#155966, 1265 Lombardi Ave league, Im looking for players.

Answer 3

I agree with the general sentiment that LT is the better pick.  BUT, if this is a keeper league and you might be able to keep the guy for ten years, Peterson is younger and stands to get you more over the long run, so I think I would lean that direction in that particular scenario.

Answer 4

LT should be the number one pick in all formats.

Answer 5

Overall you have to pick LT over Peterson.  Peterson could possibly rush for like 2,000 yards but LT does everything, he throws touchdowns, catches them, and rushes for more than Peterson does.

Answer 6

you have to take LT. he is a proven running back and gain more fantasy points than Peterson, although Peterson may be the better runner.

Answer 7

LT

Answer 8

I love both but I'd pick L.T. just because i know he is more consistent than AP but don't get me wrong, AP is still great!!!

Answer 9

pick LT he should have a better season than even Peterson.

Answer 10

i would take LT over AP anyday  because the defensive teams are going to stack the line and make tavaris jackson throw on them..AP is goin to have a sophmore slump...LT is proven himself to everyone...AP is overrated

Answer 11

The only way Peterson is a Top 5 pick is if you're drafting on August 31 and LT, Westbrook, Addai, Steven Jackson, and Tom Brady have all suffered season-ending injuries.

Peterson is overrated based upon 2 outstanding games ;ast year but consider that in the other 12 games he played (he missed 2 with an injury) he gained 821 yards on 188 carries and 6 TDs. That's an average of 68.4 yards per game and 4.13 yards per carry, hardly numbers worthy of the #2 fantasy back.