Place these fighters?

Question

Where would Floyd, Oscar, Chris Byrd, Hopkins and Riddick Bowe, michael moore, ricky hatton rank in the divisions all time list or should they even be condsidered in the top 20. Considering jr and superwelt/jr mid all as just the welterweight division, Bhop as a mid only and the rest at heavyweights.

Answer 1

i would probably put floyd ahead of  oscar on the bottom half of the list.floyd once upon a time did fight top competition when he was a lightweight,i do think he lost the 1st castillo fight but that's another story .i i do give props to oscar for fighting the top competition thru out his career,problem is he lost more of those fights than he won.as for the other fighters mabey hopkins. hatton is not even close ,he should'nt even be on the list

Answer 2

To be perfectly honest with you Oscar is the only one I would put on the list of all time greats, but he would be like 90 out of 100. Floyd would never make the list because he did nohting but duck fighters and never had a win over very big competition with the exception of one fight. Hatton was highly overrated having fought only in brittain and only once in america, which was also his first loss. Hopkins didn't even gain any recognition until he was 35. Byrd was good but doesn't measure with the greats. Bowe had a promising shot at glory but blew it big time. To be the best you have to take on all the best fighters you can from all over the world and beat them. Only oscar has done this.

Answer 3

Floyd Mayweather is the only fighter on this list that could be put on here none of the rest of these guys would get my vote Oscar has lost more fights than Mike Tyson attorney have lost cases