Pudge for Farnsworth?

Question

Who do you think got the better end of the deal?

I think the Yankees did because Farnsworth was sub-par in my opinion.

Answer 1

Farnsworth had just finished a stretch of like 11 straight innings without giving up a hit, so he was hardly sub-par. But with getting Damaso Marte from the Pirates I guess they felt they didn't need Farnsworth anymore.

Answer 2

Neither team got much. Fawnsworth has already sucked in Detroit, and as Yankee fans will find out, Pudge up with runners on equals end of inning.

Answer 3

they both got a s**+* deal.

pudge is past his prime and he hasn't been able to use his steroids anymore.

farnsworth is either hot or cold.

yankees were stupid for getting rid of a pitcher when that's all they really need.

tigers suck this year either way, so they are screwed.

i'm a yankee fan, but i'm annoyed with the trades lately.

Answer 4

The Yankees got the better deal. They replaced Posada with Pudge, and got rid of Mr. (Home-run) Farnsworth.

Answer 5

I like the move, the Yankees sold high and filled a gap behind the plate with excess from the bullpen

Answer 6

Cashman must have a raygun that turns other GM's into morons.  All I have to say about this year's transactions.

Answer 7

The Yankees of course. Kyle Farnsworth-less for 14 time All-Star Pudge Rodriguez? I'd take Pudge anyday! Pudge completes the Yankee lineup now. Instead of having batters pitched around to get to Molina, Pudge adds a threat with a bat, and now an arm to go with it. This should make for an interesting last 2 months of regular season baseball.

Answer 8

yanks for sure... 14 time all-star??

Answer 9

i say neither one because i really didn't like Farnsworth when he was with the cubs he was turning out to be another latroy hawkens and I'm just glad that he was traded far way.

Answer 10

the yankees got a great deal. i always hated farnsworthless even though he is having a good year.