QB Challenge/Better QB?

Question

2 Questions in one.

1: Who is the better QB of this two. This is from 1 game.

Me: 12-14, 4 TD's, 1 INT, 0 Sacks, 0 Fumbles, 35 rushing yards, 145 passing yards.

opponet: 15-20, 2 TD's, 2 INT, 1 Sack, 1 Fumble, 0 Rushing yards, 132 pass yards.

And his receiver/defesne guy is 5'10 and plays WR and MLB my guys was a 5'0 soccer star,

Question 2:

I'm trying tofind a way to have a challenge to see who is better. Any ideas, P.S. we only have 4-6 people.

Answer 1

I don't really think you could determine who is a better QB based on just 1 game or by playing a challenge. Also, no idea to tell how well match the teams are. You are only playing one position.

Have you considered switching teams with the other QB to see what the numbers look like?

Answer 2

I would say you are the better QB because the other guy had two turnovers. Turnovers are the worst thing in football; at any level.

Not sure what you mean about the second question.

Answer 3

you did better.

Award points for %, TDs, etc.

Example: For every 5% completed give 1 point. SO if you completed 30% of your passdes you'd get 6 points.

Give 2 points for TDs

Minus 1 point for an INT

Minus .5 point for a sack

Minus 1 point for a fumble

1 point for every 20 rushing yards

1 point for every 20 passing yards

You: 33 points

Opponent: 21.5 points