Rate My Keeper Draft?

Question

So this is my second season in a keeper league (the first season we've had something to keep)... Each team was able to keep up to three of the players from last year's roster, but had to forego the round in which they were drafted last season. Interesting dynamic in that sleeper studs from last year could be kept at nominal costs this year... i.e. Adrian Peterson for a 6th round pick, Braylon Edwards for an 8th round pick and Wes Welker for a 13th round pick, etc. The side-effect of this dynamic, is that during this years 1st and 2nd rounds, those with picks found themselves themselves in some cases picking from 3rd or 4th round caliber players.

I had the 9th pick in a 10 team league. 1 point per reception and 0.5 point per completion. 17 roster spots. Here's how I did:

1) Frank Gore (keeper)

2) Reggie Bush (12)

3) Brandon Marshall (29)

4) Marcus Colston (keeper)

5) Rashard Mendenhall (49)

6) Jericho Cotchery (52)

7) Julius Jones (69)

8) Kevin Curtis (72)

9) Kellen Winslow (keeper)

10) Jay Cutler (92)

11) Green Bay Defense (109)

12) Chris Johnson (112)

13) Mark Clayton (129)

14) Pierre Thomas (132)

15) Rob Bironas (149)

16) Jon Kitna (152)

17) Devin Thomas (169)

What do you think?

Answer 1

Odd way to get keepers but okay you shouldn't have picked Reggie Bush with the 2 pick And why did you pick Brandon Marshall a lot of questionable picks but a 6/10 overall.

Answer 2

i like who you kept with all of them being solid producers this year

RBS id give them a 5 because bush could be great or he could suck, gore is solid because you get points per catch mendenhall will get carries and some goal line carries

QBs id give you 7 because cutler will be good this year when marshall comes back and kitna is a solid backup good job drafting your QBS

WRS get 9 with marshall and colston could be #1 on any of team in your league and got them to be a #2 and then I love the cotchery pick with farve at QB backups are very good

TE is best in the league so he gets a 9.5

Def gets a 8 because they arent gonna take off as much clock with rodgers leading the way like farve did so there will be more time for opponents to score

overall i think you deserve a 9 good draft and i think you have a good chance at winning your league