Should I make this Fantasy trade?

Question

I get:

Mark Teixiera (36 R, 10 HR, 45 RBI, .270 BA)

Nate McLouth (53 R, 14 HR, 46 RBI, .304 BA)

George Sherrill (21 SV, 28 K, 2.38 ERA, 1.08 WHIP)

I give up:

Adrian Gonzalez (42 R, 18 HR, 60 RBI, .295 BA)

Miguel Cabrera (30 R, 9 HR, 39 RBI, .278 BA)

My team:

Jason Varitek

Adrian Gonzalez

Ian Kinsler

Kevin Youkilis

Yunel Escobar

J.D. Drew

Jermaine Dye

Xavier Nady

Shane Victorino

David Murphy

Miguel Cabrera

Kelly Johnson

Edgar Renteria

Eric Brynes-DL

Cliff Lee

Todd Wellemeyer

Jonathan Papelbon

Brian Fuentes

Micah Owings

Ryan Dempster

Aaron Cook

Gavin Floyd

Jake Peavy

Dice-K-DL

His team:

Joe Mauer

Mark Teixiera

Alexei Ramirez

Mark DeRosa

Jose Reyes

Bobby Abreu

BJ Upton

Jose Guillen

Nate McLouth

Maicer Izturis

Howie Kendrick

Clint Barmes-DL

Javier Vasquez

Justin Verlander

Kerry Wood

Brad Lidge

C.C. Sabathia

John Lackey

George Sherril

Chad Billingsley

Clayton Kershaw

Erik Bedard

Ervin Santana

I know I'm giving up HR in Gonzalez and Cabrera, but i need saves. Accept, reject or counter?

Answer 1

Absolutley.  You should accept, although it is extemely unfair for the othe person.  Mark Teixeira always heats up later in the season and Nate McLouth has been great all year.  You also get a 21 save pitcher, not too many of those.

Answer 2

definetly do it.

go to fantasybaseballcafe.com

best fantasy site ever. post ur team, ask them questions like this and have a great time ;)

Answer 3

DECLINE. GOOD LUCK.

Answer 4

h**l yea, take it.  Gonzalez has peaked and Tigers players are worthless.

Answer 5

in a heart beat......