Should I take this deal?

Question

I was offered:

Miguel Tejada

Manny Ramirez

Hunter Pence

Fred Lewis

FOR

Hanley Ramirez

Carlos Quentin

Jay Bruce

Should I take it? One one hand, Quentin and Bruce haven't played well at all in the last month.. but neither have any of the guys I would be getting back.

My current team:

C - Jorge Posada

1B - Jason Giambi

2B - BJ Upton

3B - Ryan Braun

SS - Hanley Ramirez

IF - Marcus Thames

OF - Carlos Quentin

OF - Carlos Lee

OF - Ryan Ludwick

OF - Jay Bruce

UT - John Bowker

UT - Billy Butler

BN - Casey Blake

SP - Brandon Wood

SP - Cole Hamels

SP - Ryan Dempster

RP - Trevor Hoffman

RP - Joakim Soria

P - Justin Duchscherer

P - Manny Parra

P - streaming position

DL - Shaun Marcum

Answer 1

definetly it couldnt hurt      your team you already have

Answer 2

Do not take it!!!!  Hanley is an MVP canidate Quentin has put up amazing numbers this year.  Bruce is on back on the rise.  Manny is not at full health and with no ortiz in front of him hes not gonna get as many rbis as ussal.Pence is having an average season Fred Lewis is garbage.  Tejada is having a good season but its a big step down from Hanley.

Answer 3

Hanley ramirez has having a real good season , but i dont about miguel tejada i havent been following his  numbers. I would take it you get power with manny, and Fred Lewis is a good player with 20/20 potenital

Answer 4

Heck no.  Bruce is hitting again now, Hanley is awesome, and Quentin is a RBI machine.  The guy who offered you this trade is hoping their Names will blind you from seeing their stats, both on his players and yours.  Clever, but dont fall for it.

Answer 5

If your looking to start your roster over go ahead.