Trade offer on the table?

Question

Pat Burrell and Carl Crawford

For

Carlos Guillen and Matt Holliday

which two would you rather have?

Answer 1

Guillen and Holliday.

Answer 2

got to hold on to crawford cause he's gonna lead the league in stolen bases and holiday can't hit on the road. I'd do burrell for holiday

Answer 3

they are both lame

Answer 4

Holliday and Guillen.

Both provide high averages and can drive in runs.  Holliday plays in Colorado as the star player. Guillen is consistant for Detroit and with that lineup, it makes him better.

Burrell has a tendency to go on a streak but then goes into a BIG slump.  Crawford is a 5 tool player, but isn't having an All-Star year.

Answer 5

I would rather have Holliday and Guillen both are hot

Answer 6

niether..