Vazquez for Saunders...Good deal?

Question

I have Javier Vazquez and Dave Murphy...I'm being offered Justin Upton, Mike Jacobs and Joe Saunders.

Is this a good deal and why?

Answer 1

This sounds like a good deal because you're getting some depth in your lineup and receiving a no.1 starter in Saunders that's having a better year than Vasquez, so do this deal.

Answer 2

Vazquez is much more valuable because he strikes people out. Saunders might get wins now, but he wont get many in the future and he has never had big strikeout numbers. You can expect around 15 out of Vazquez. As for the rest, I would keep Murphy.

Answer 3

upton is overrated. jacobs will hit 260 for u and hit 30+ home runs probably. Vazquez>Saunders