Which sat nav is better?

Question

Im looking to buy my first satnav, under £150, but which is better? At the moment my fav. is probably the Sony because its affordable and its a Sony.

But I want second opinions...The list below is what I think is wrth under £150..however if you think there is something better tellme and I will look at. Under £150 only please!

Sony NVU53 XL widescreen (£99.99)

Navman S30 / S50 (£130 / £150)

TomTom One (£120)

Garmin 610T / Nuvi 300 (£150 / £90)

Thanks v.much!

Answer 1

I use the TomTom & find it pretty good. If you  ignore the instructions it just recalculates & gets you there anyway without fuss, which is better than most human mapreaders!

Answer 2

I'll take Tom Tom over others anyday. Garmin is good 2nd choice.

I have pretty low opinion of Sony's products that are not Music or TV related.