Who wins this trade? BBB!?

Question

Team A gets:

1B P. Fielder

2B R. Cano

SS E. Renteria

3B K. Youkillis

OF A. Soriano

Team B gets:

1B A. Gonzalez

2B C. Utley

SS R. Furcal

3B A. Ramirez

RP G. Sherrill

Who wins this trade? Why?

Answer 1

Team B in a landslide.  Just Gonzo and Utley by themselves is better than the package Team A receives. Soriano, Youkilis, and Renteria are having good years, but Furcal can't stay healthy and Fielder is having a power outage, although he can turn on the juice at any time.  

If you're Team B, take the trade, hope it doesn't get vetoed and have a good year.

Answer 2

Team B. Utley, Ramirez and Furcal make team B a better choice.

Answer 3

I have to agree with Fenway from above. Team B gets a huge win for this one. That will be within a few votes of an All Star starting infield, with Gonzalez,  Utley, Furcal, and Ramirez....

Answer 4

Team B but it depends on what the team need

But B gets the Better deal because they get utley and gonzo who are studs and Furcal who is batting like 350 but injury prone and Aram who plays in one of the Best Lineups in baseball

Answer 5

Oh my goodness this is complicated.

Wow i think team B wins by a LONG shot. I would be surprised if it doesnt get vetoed.

Gonzalez and Fielder are bascially a wash but Ill give Prince the slight edge because he his hitting in a better environment and hes heating up. However its very slgiht because Gonza has shown he can hit in petco.

Utley is way way way better than Cano. Cano is extremely streaky but Utley as of now he is the best player in baseball.

I said this to your other question but Furcal is ebtter when hes palying but that risk is something thats dangerous because hes had these problems before. however, youve had him for this long, just wait it out. So plus furcal here.

Then we compare Aram vs. Soriano. Aram is significantly better. I think hes gonna give you better stats every where except for steals but tahts where the problem is. Soriano is not going to run. i dont care what all these Cubs fan say. Hes not gonna run. Last year he had a leg injury and he barely ran at all. Soriano wont wun. He on pace for like 12 steals and i would actaully take the under on than. Aram gest the edge.

And Sherrill has 20 saves. Eve for a mediocre team like the Os, hes getting the saves so hes valuable. Youk on the other hand is a NOTOIOUS fader as the season wears on. SHerrill plus.

I think Team B just r@ped team A in this trade. Fingers crossed its not vetoed.

Answer 6

team b utley is on a big streak