Rewriting History???

Question

Rewriting history according to Hitler, and the pathetic display of Bob Dylan`s (Zimmerman) birth certificate with `Jewish` entered into the area describing `race`....

I believe Dylan was born in Minnesota which in the days before the Ethnic invasion asked for your race.

However, if you don`t believe me, check it out on the internet. In none of the 52 states of America (in the Forties) and before the Supreme Court quoshed the racism laws was a Jew considered to have been of another `race`.

Hitler was absolutely and totally singular in adapting this political position; and as I have said before, he was a pawn of the lunatic fringe of the Catholic Church.

States were very up front in listing excluded ethnicities and these includes Filipinos, hispanics, blacks, Asians, and American Indians.

Only in hindsight and given the antiSemitism of modern times are they trying to disenfranchise Jews.

We all have some Roman blood, even the ancient Britons.

Answer 1

I'm not sure what your question is either.  It is true that race is often thought of differently through generations.  I don't recall what you mentioned about Jews being considered a race.  However in many of the documents I have seen prior to WWII, they do often ask for religion.  This was the case for my Jewish ancestors that came to this country.  Of course, they didn't come to Minnesota; and although I live in Minnesota, I have not seen what you are discribing---not to say that it isn't here.

All states do ask for race on the birth records today.  So, what is the problem?

Also how was Hitler a pawn for the Catholic Church.  If this was so, it would have been unknown to him.  Sure, he was born a  Catholic, christened Catholic, and officially died as a Catholic.  His public speaches enforced Christianity of sorts.  However, in his private life it was evident that he did not really believe in the faith so strongly.  He felt that Christianity was started by the Jews and it's introduction was a big mistake.  He also felt that it deserved a slow death.  He knew full well that he would not gain as much support from the Germans if he made these thoughts public.  He used the Christianity angle to appeal to his fellow Germans.  He was a charasmatic leader that used whatever he could to his benefit.  Although, I can't deny that he had some faith since he was a bit obsessed with finding Christian artifacts.  I can't help but wonder if he was just planning to use those in the way he used Christianity and his Catholic baground to his benefit.  So, I think if anything, you have it turned around  The Catholic Church wasa pawn for Adolf Hitler---but surely not willingly.

Also, I would like to add, that there are a lot of people that don't have Roman blood.  True, most Western Europeans and probably a lot of Americans have it, but there are a lot more people in this world that don't have any Roman ancestry.  Their influence was not that widespread on a world-wide scale.

Answer 2

not to sure of your question but if bob considers himself jewish then he should be able to corect any error/oversight on his documents

im from new zealand i am a Kiwi ( americans are sometimes referred to as yanks) yet on govt forms you were classed as "european" even thoe its been numerous generations since my family has been anywhere near europe. i just answered as being "other" -KIwi and often got told couldn't do that

so hitler and the churches are not alone in dictating your race declarations