Ricky Hatton vs Miguel Cotto at 140 Lbs?

Question

Who would have won if Miguel Cotto when fought Kelson Pinto or Abdullaev (in that time he was fit as super lightweight and not hungry, starved or weak like he was in 2006) fought Ricky Hatton who defeated Tszyu, at Super lightweight (140 Lbs/63 Kgs)? Who would have won between those two version of Cotto and Hatton?

Answer 1

You are not my boyfriend, right ?  Same name !! He is from Italy.

These 2 fighters are pretty close in my opinion and may end up a split decision, mostly depending on the immediate performance and mentality of both fighters druing the fight, but I would go for Cotto for a slight margin winning over Hatten as because Cotto throws more power punches although he is kind of slow.  Ricky Hatten may fight a little faster than Cotto but not as super fast as Mayweather and doesn't throw punches as powerful as Cotto,  Hatten's speed may reduce after 4 or 5 rounds and may give Cotto less threats from that onward.

Anyway, should be a very close fight.

Answer 2

hatton was unstoppable at one stage, every contender that came his way hatton would dismantle, look at the record they both have, it tells the story of hatton being better in any point of there career, all them so called big named fights that cotto has had, well wtf's a name ye? so what if they are chinese, mexican , puerto rican , american,african,european....it doesnt matter about names, so that cant be used as an excuse for people saying well....cotto fought bigger names, because thats bull, hatton destroyed everyone in his path in junior welterweight division, i am a huge cotto fan and hatton fan, as well as many other boxers, but its just hands down hatton here, hatton wins by KO in the 7th round. ye so cotto beat judah, look what tszyu did to judah, and look what hatton did to tszyu.

Answer 3

Who cares Margartio would kick both thier asses.

Answer 4

COTTO HANDS DOWN.. I THOUGHT HATTON WAS GOOD AT ONE POINT, BUT THEN HE FOUGHT SCARY MAYWEATHER AND GOT KNOCKED OUT COLD WITH A PUNCH TO THE CHIN.. IT WAS A GOOD PUNCH BUT STILL HATTON LOST ALL THE RESPECT I HAD FOR HIM.. HATTON HAS NO MORE POWER LEFT IN HIM ONLY IF HE FIGHTS WEAKER FIGHTERS MAYBE.. BUT COTTO WOULD MAN HANDLE HIM.. NO MATTER COTTO'S LOST HE IS STILL A GOOD CONTENDER BUT NOT FOR MARGARITO..