Ricky Williams or Johnathan Stewart?

Question

I have stewart right now and i'm looking for long term value. Got an offer to trade him for Ricky Williams.

Stewart i think is very likely to get the starting job and i definitely think he'll be getting goalline but he is a rookie.

Is this a good trade?

note: i have Ronnie Brown already.

Answer 1

i think for the first few games, DeAngelo williams will start

so i'd go with either Ricky or Ronnie...but probably Ricky

Answer 2

i would do the trade, i think Ricky will have a pretty good year, Ronnie Brown is pretty banged up.

Answer 3

rather have stewart cause he has more upside.  But it depends on who your other running backs are.  If this is just for like a flex position or bench  than keep stewart.  if this is for your 2nd rounning back position than consider the deal just so between ronnie and ricky u have 1 starter, more stability in having ronnie and ricky, but lot less upside.  

Answer 4

I would stick with Brown and Stewart, though because the thumb injury Brown may start a bit slowly. Brown, if healthy will still get the majority of the work for the dolphins. Of course, as everything is in the NFL it all depends on the health of the players.

Answer 5

stewart