Romo, steve smith(panthers), and michael turner for derrick anderson, brandon marshall, and ryan grant?

Question

should i trade romo, smith, and turner for anderson, marshall,and grant? my other recievers are t.o, reggie wayne, and lee evans, and my other backs are ronnie brown, rudi johnson, and cheste taylor, with jay cutler as my back up qb.

Answer 1

NO! your making a big mistake if you do that. dont sabotage your team.

Answer 2

It's an apples-for-apples trade.  As others have said, you need more help at RB than WR, so losing Smith and getting Grant could help you in some ways.  But I would see if you could keep Romo and trade Smith and Turner for a more elite back.  Or, even just Smith and Turner for Marshall and Grant.  

Romo is probably the best value here, with Grant second and then Smith and Anderson close behind and Turner and Marshall bringing up the rear.  So, basically, this trade is slightly skewed toward the person who gets Romo.  But there isn't a bad player here.  If you think it is worth it for Grant, go for it, but otherwise, I think you're OK either way.  My preference would be the Romo-Smith-Turner side of the trade.

Answer 3

Take it i say.  Romo and Anderson are pretty equal, plus Anderson has way better targets in Braylon Edwards, Kellen Winslow Jr. and Donte Stallworth.  Grant is far better than Turner and you are already set at WR so you can afford to lose Smith. There is no guarantee that Delhomme will be back to his old form after his injury anyway. Your running backs could be Ronnie Brown, Chester Taylor, and Ryan Grant with Rudi's f****s on the bench where it belongs. You'd be set.

Answer 4

bro it sounds like you really hit the c**p shoot on running backs. still, the trade is bad. grant played for 2 months last year. i honestly believe turner will have a better year than grant in a run heavy atlanta offense, and tony romo will clearly out pass anderson.  this is the dallas cowboys they are a championship contender, you should want players on a championship caliber team. the browns are a 10-6 wild card at best, although anderson has shown some very nice talent.  this is fantasy, and romo gets TDs, tons of them. lastly, brandon marshall had a heck of a year but cutler isnt the greatest tool in the shed although he probably is a tool, and steve smith has shown absolute freakish ability at times in his career. i'd take a chance on smith because with a healthy delhomme, he is godly.

decline the trade

Answer 5

Terrible offer. Romo is a far better option than Anderson, Steve Smith has Delhomme back and is a stud (plus Marshall is facing a possible suspension) and Turner for Grant is at this point a wash. Niether has established themselves as an elite back, both have that potential so you might as well stick with Turner and see if he can put up numbers in Atlanta. This guy needs to make a whole lot better offer before you can consider a trade, the numbers just arent that close. Bottom line....DONT do it!

Answer 6

You need to rethink this whole deal.

Brandon Marshall has a pending DUI case, and faces multiple assualt and domestic abuse charges in Georgia.

There's a better than average chance that he'll be suspended for a portion of the season.

Your trading partner needs to give you a non-criminal in the deal.

Answer 7

no way, you should kick him in the nuts for even offering you a trade this bad.

IN THE NUTS, I SAY.