Rookies of the year?

Question

NL-Jay Bruce, AL-Evan Longoria

Agree? Disagree?

Answer 1

love your picks but also a reds fan and seen how well Bruce has performed and Longoria on the Rays has done well, also.

Answer 2

AL = Longoria for sure, hasn't been up the whole year (but practically all of it) and has been performing like someone who has already been around the block a few years

NL = Jair Jurjjens... he's got 10 wins, almost 100 K's, and has a top notch ERA at 3.12 can't get much better than that... his WHIP is also pretty good, at 1.31

Answer 3

Disagree. David Murphy for AL ROTY.

Answer 4

As much as I hate it Soto is the better choice for the NL.  Longoria is head and shoulders above anyone in the AL, especially any loser from Boston.

Answer 5

Definitely Longoria for the AL; he's an All-Star and a great all around player.  But Bruce was really only exciting for the first few weeks of his career, now he's mediocre.  The NL honors will be probably go to Soto of the Cubs.  He is already among the top catchers in the league this year.

Answer 6

I disagree.  I say Longoria and Geovany Soto

Answer 7

Disagree

NL- Soto

AL- Longoria

Answer 8

Disagree NL-Jay Bruce AL-Jacoby Ellsbury

Answer 9

no argument here. 2 pts.

Answer 10

I agree with Longoria but Bruce hasn't produced at all. He had a hot start then just went cold. I'll go with Jair Jurjens(I can't spell) or Padres reliever Mike Adams. He's pretty good

Answer 11

I like Soto in the NL.

Reluctantly, I have to concede Ellsbury in favor of Longoria.