Ryan Grant or McFadden in a keeper league

Question

I am in a keeper league, if you don't know what that is please don't answer. I have the first overall pick and the best two backs available in our league are the ones previously listed. We play yahoo standard format. Who would you take?

Answer 1

Grant. McFadden hasn't played a down in the NFL, and we won't know how he'll do. Once Grant gets this contract situation solved, he'll be back to his old self, playing like he did last year.

Answer 2

Grant because he is a proven NFL commodity, almost the same age as McFadden and has done great things in the playoffs. That is the proof of a gamer vs. McFadden who has character flaws such as a brother who sold crack to his own Mom and 13 brothers and sisters to feed financially.

Plus Packers have a great supporting cast making it hard to put 8 men in the box. Grant won me a Fantasy championship last year so Im a little bit biased but seriously...did you know this...

DARREN MCFADDEN LED THE NCAA...NOT HIS TEAM, CONFERENCE, OR WHATEVER IN A TERRIBLE CATEGORY....MOST FUMBLES!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DMAC while an explosive player doesnt have strong legs, character issues, an NFL track record, a another RB who played well in Fargas in his backfield, and PROVEN fumblitis.

Grant I see nothing but positives, for this year or next year. Raiders will be lucky to win 7-8 games next year, Green Bay will be competing for a Superbowl.

DONT SELL YOURSELF ON s**y, SELL YOURSELF ON PRODUCTION!

NOW GO OUT THERE AND WIN A CHAMPIONSHIP!!!!!

Answer 3

GRANT MC GRANT GRANT. MCFAD MAY BE NEXT YR BUT HE ALSO MIGHT BE A BUST. GRANT HAS MORE POTENTIAL BECAUSE OF WHAT HE SHOWED LAST SEASON.

Answer 4

ok i would say that u cant tell dont make a desecion till draft day just trust me they both r unproven and no one nos how both are gonna do so dont make a desecion till draft day!!!!!!!!!!

good luck

Answer 5

Grant.