SHIVERING ISLES: Should I become the duke of Mania or Dementia?

Question

What are the pros and cons?

Answer 1

Their really isn't any pros or cons.  It all depends on whether you would like to control the Dark Seducers or Golden Saints.  I like the Dark Seducers cause they aren't *****.

Whatever you do, save your game beforehand that way you can replay the decision and get both achievements.  You only get to pick one, so be smart and pick the other one when you reload.  I have to start my game over because I forgot to do so and that is the only achievement I'm missing.