San Juan or St. Thomas for a romantic week vacation?

Question

My husband and I are going on a trip to celebrate our 5 yr anniversary. He is letting me plan the whole thing. Which would be better San Juan or an all inclusive in St. Thomas?

Answer 1

St. Thomas for sure.

Answer 2

I've been to both islands( my grandparents are from St. Thomas). There are no specific trade-offs. Go with the package that is cheapest  or flip a coin. You two will have a great time no matter where you go. it's your 5th honeymoon. Congratulations! Enjoy!