Second opinion on this trade?

Question

I give Marshawn Lynch

I get Torry Holt, Willis McGahee, and L.J. Smith

I'm thinking no because of the injury risks that Holt and McGahee pose, but another opinion would be helpful

Answer 1

holt will be fine. the only problem is willis mcgahee. he's probably going to miss the first few games for the ravens. if you expect big numbers during his return, then do the trade. also lj smith is a big sleeper candidate, donovan mcnabb needs weapons, so he might be good.

Answer 2

Mcgahee is a huge risk and i dont think smith will be productive. Holt should have a good year, but lynch loves applebees in buffalo (willis mcgahee said he hated buffalo) and lynch also puts out (like jays mother) points

Answer 3

I would do that.  Your getting an all pro in holt, Mcgahee wont light it up but it decent.  LJ Smith is ok, not great.  You can even do this and then have trade bait and put a package deal together and trade Holt or whoever else you have for a better RB then Lynch.  Lynch has only played one season, so nobody really knows if he is gonna be great

Answer 4

I would not trade Lynch as he is an all down back on a running team, and is a fantasy stud.