Self tanner...Jergens gradual tan or Dove Energy Glow?

Question

Which one has a better color...I'm so pale with yellow undertones and certainly don't want to look orange! Thanks!

Answer 1

Jergens is great because it never gets orange-y and changes to blend into your natural skin tone. I love it!

Answer 2

I too am very pale and I used the Dove Energy Glow for fair/medium skin.  I thought it was a very natural color.  Just make sure after you apply it that you wash your hands.  I have never used the Jergens so I can't tell you how that works.  

Answer 3

ive pretty pale my self. and Dove energy glow is my favorite. and it doesnt go on streaky either.

Answer 4

jergens works really well.  it tans really fast but it has a smell that smells like a washed up miley cyrus, BLAH!!

Answer 5

I'm using dove right now, it works really well, I'm not orange. i keep asking everyone if im orange and they so no  ha. i used jergens and it doesnt really work. i saw nothing change.

Answer 6

Jergens Natural Glow has been the only self tanner that does not turn me orange. Since you are pale go with the one for light skin, 3 days of use and your skin should have a "glow" to it. If after 3 days it is too dark and looks kinda orangish around your ankle area, then cut back to doing it every other day and it will even out. It is all about finding a routine that works best for you. It always helps it look even more natural if you have a little base tan, but I understand the dangers of the sun and people's worries, so it is not completely necessary. Unfortunately I know nothing about Dove Energy Glow.  

Answer 7

i prefer Dove  it looks more natural

Answer 8

my mom has always used Dove Energy Glow. it works really well and she looks great!! ive used it a few times too. good luck hope this helps!

Answer 9

try both.

olay touch of sun is good too

Answer 10

Jergen's is horrorible, it streaks, and looks bad. I haven't used Dove, but it's probably better then Jergens. The best stuff I've ever tried was Sally Hansen spray tan, actually looked natural and no streaks!

Answer 11

i have never had luck with any of these. they all turn out kind of orange....also; after you shower...a lot of it comes off and streaks when you shave your legs.

Answer 12

i tried jergens before and it made me orange, i think going to a tanning bed worked the best for me.

Answer 13

neither work, try L'Oreal ones, you acctually see a difference in three days of using it twice a day!! really a natural bronze glow!!