Settlers of Catan?

Question

Imagine this scenario:

Player 1 has the Longest Road with 10 segments.

Player 2 and Player 3 are tied with 9 segments.

Player 2 builds a settlement and cuts Player 1's road in half.

Since Player 2 and Player 3 are now tied for the Longest Road with 9 each, what happens to the Longest Road card? Does Player 2 get it because he/she is the active player that destroyed the road? Or does it get set aside until someone builds another segment?

Answer 1

Gene probably got his reference from here:

http://www.universityofcatan.com/faq/faq...

"Q:   If Player A has a road that is 5 pieces long, and player B then builds a road that's 5 long, who gets the Longest Road bonus? To interpret the rules literally, it would seem that player A keeps the bonus tile until someone else builds a LONGER road (i.e., 6 or more), which would reward the player who has not just the longest road, but the first-and-longest road. Is this correct? Or does the bonus go away when 2 or more players have the same length longest road?

A: If a player has the longest road, he retains the longest road card and it's two victory points until another player builds a road that is longer than his. So, player B would have to build a road of 6 segments in order to take the longest road card from player A. Of course, player A can make his road longer, so that player B would have to build even more segments before he takes it away.

The longest road card is retained by it's current owner until one of two things happen:

1. Another player builds a road that is then longer than the longest road of the current card-holder. In this case, the new longest road owner takes the longest road card.

2. The longest road is broken by the placement of a settlement along its length (remember to obey the 2-step rule). In this case, everyone must check to see who has the longest road. If any single player has the longest road (note that it could be the same as the old player with the longest road) than that player takes the card and the two points. If more than one player has the longest road, or if no player has a road of at least 5 segments, then no one gets the longest road card and it is set aside. As soon as any player builds a longest road of at least 5 segments, then he may claim the card as normal."

Happy gaming!

Answer 2

The Longest road card would get set aside. No player has overall control.

I have either read that in the rules book or a Q & A settlers web site.