Shawn Johnson or Nastia Liukin?

Question

who do you think is a better gymnast?

Answer 1

Both excellent!

Nastia had longer legs which makes it look a bit more elegant...

However Shawn Johnson definitely got my vote, she is so confident and friendly and her smile is the best I have seen so far!

She is the best at what she does and so confident.. and that is what a true American and a true champion should be... unlike some losers here going on and on about how bad this and that is....

Answer 2

Nastia Liukin...the combination of grace and beauty.

Answer 3

Nastia....more medals

Answer 4

Nastia is more elegant but Shawn is more "powerful". It really depends on what you prefer.  

Answer 5

It's pretty close... although Shawn is more of a power house for things like the vault, and such I think I'll have to go with Nastia... she broke out of her shell finally in the all around at the appropriate time and she's a bit taller so she can throw down her lines with more elegance and grace... she may not be the strongest gymnast but what she lacks there she makes up in the artistry of her routines which is also a very important part of gymnastics... however, Nastia is turning 19 in October and Shawn is still only 16, so i think Shawn will better than Nastia in a couple years time

Answer 6

Nastia is much more elegant.

Answer 7

Johnson..BUT only because of her magical left eyebrow.  

Answer 8

shawn is the better gymnast by skill and by personality. nastia however did better at the olympics.

Answer 9

Nastia performed better at the Olympics, but Shawn is the better gymnast

Answer 10

i think their both amazing. But Shawn's got so much more personality that just shines threw, and shes usually better. But Nastia's really graceful. But I like Shawn better:)

Answer 11

hmmm who won more medals, who won the all around, oh yeah that would be nastia liukin

Answer 12

Well, they are both brilliant, they can do a cartwheel better than i can!! i love Shawn tho, she is too cute :)