Should Colt Brennan start over jason cambell

Question

Should Colt Brennan start over jason cambell

Answer 1

i think that he needs to be a little better but from the performance he showed against the colts ya  he will be good soon

Answer 2

No.

Campbell has more experience, and when healthy has some real upside.

I think what we've seen from Brennan so far suggests that he was worthy of selection.

However, people forget that defenses are steeply "dumbed down" in the preseason.  They rarely reveal blitz packages or any degree of complexity.

It's way too early to make anything of this.

From a fantasy persepctive, rookie QBs are usually good for an emergency bye week start, and keeper prospects, little more.

Answer 3

No!  Rookie QB's have been known for playing horrible.  He at least needs a year or two under his belt and then he can take over the reigns.  

Answer 4

Not this year. He should play a bit this yr but not start. Rookie QBs never do good they need a yr or two first

Answer 5

Even though this IS colt brennan we are talking about, jason campbell should be used. I think Colt Brennan is a monster at throwing TD's, but he is just a rookie. he needs experience. play him during games already won, give him some experience on the field. A quarter, a half, little by little to train him

Answer 6

You must not have watched the bowl game against Georgia...He sucked.  

Answer 7

It is WAY too early to make this decision. Colt's played PART of ONE game. That's it. Can't bank your season on a rookie without seeing him in significant action over a period of time. Heck, he probably doesn't even know the entire play book yet. Give him some time!

Answer 8

As an Eagles fan, I say yes!!

Answer 9

no its just a presason game aginst backups