Should England drop Vaughan??

Question

Vaughan has now scored a grand total of two against South Africa (falling for a duck in the first Innings of the Second test). If he wasn't the Captain it would have been him not Collingwood who was dropped to make way for Flintoff.

Is it time for Vaughan to resign as Captain so he can make way for someone who can score at no. 3 in the batting order or should the selectors just drop him without waiting for him to resign the Captaincy?

Answer 1

No he shouldn't, he should be afforded the chance to show what he can do and to see if he can regain his form (and besides it wasn't all that long ago that he scored a century against NZ). Collingwood has been out of form for a lot longer than Vaughan has and it was right that he made way. I don't see the point in chopping and changing the team to much and too often.

And I doubt the selectors would drop Vaughan before the Ashes, they'll probably give him the chance to regain them and then he'll probably retire anyway.

On a side note I got my Top Contributer badge back!

Answer 2

no he should not after all england cricket board does not follow BCCI!!

Answer 3

No. When teams start dropping normally good players for having a bad spell, they are in trouble.They should give them a reasonable chance to get back to their best before dropping them.

Answer 4

No. There is something in him still for English Cricket.

Answer 5

Yes Vaughan should be dropped bcuz there are many new players who's future are very bright & make England a Champion

Answer 6

no he shouldnt be dropped.

he has got the abilty to bat well. Aswell as a terrific test captain.

He was superb against New Zealand and just needs a chance to show his form against South Africa.

Answer 7

No.. one or two failures even one series failure has not matter to experience compainer

Answer 8

No.

Answer 9

ya

Answer 10

no