Should I Do This Deal? Please help out a newb!

Question

well heres the deal

I get Vernon Davis(TE) and Willis McGahee(RB)

I give Dallas Clark(TE)

Note: I have the option of getting Brandon Jacobs

The person I'm dealing already has LT and LJ as his starters but his starting TE is davis

I already have Witten as my starting TE (got clark in a deal) but i need a backup RB for stephen jackson and Maurice Jones-Drew

should i do this deal and is it fair why or why not

Answer 1

If you got Witten, your allready set pretty much, looks to be a good trade, you can trade off Davis than for someone else you need (or try and get the guy to give you someone other than davis)

Answer 2

I'd try to get a better RB out of the deal.  Youre already set with Witten anyways, don't make this guys team even better by letting him get Clark!

Answer 3

Definately take the trade.

You pick up a starting RB that will get plenty of carries for a TE that didn't do much last season.

McGahee is an excellent back up for Jackson and Jones-Drew.

But, at the same time, if you can get Jacobs instead of McGahee, you will be better off.

Jacobs will get the TDs while McGahee will probably not carry the ball in the red zone.

Answer 4

If you want a better running back I would hold off for a better trade. You have the best two TE in the league so you have good bargaining room. McGahee won't have a good season. Bad team and weak line...

Answer 5

I would do the trade but I would go for Jacobs instead of McGahee....good luck

Answer 6

WTF!!

Answer 7

If you have Witten then you don't need Clark trade him now.  Try to get a better running back and just don't even bother with Davis.

Answer 8

I would do this trade.  You get a Top 10 RB and also get a better TE in Davis than Clark.  

Davis will have a huge year this year.  Do it and good luck!