Should I accept? Please help!!?

Question

Ok, heres the trade:

I give Michael Young and Derrek Lee

I get Victor Martinez and Jimmy Rollins

Please tell me what to do. I love Lee and Young, but Martinez and Rollins are hard players to say no to.

Please help!! Thanks!!

Answer 1

I'd say no.. right now.  Those two guys are way under producing this year.. especially Martinez who doesn't even have a HR.

No way I would do it..  I wouldn't even give up just Derrick Lee for them two

Answer 2

It's not a good idea, Martinez has bad power numbers that haven't got any better and Rollins is still rusty from his early season injuries. Lee is a consistent player and has great durability and Young brings young talent and can hit for a decent average.

Answer 3

I can't believe this, I would accept this trade in a heartbeat.

It may seem like Rollins is underperforming this year, but he was injured for about a month. He's a definite first round pick and is, by far, the best player in the deal. V-Mart's lack of power is a concern, but I'm sure he'll begin to hit them soon. Even if he only winds up with 15 HR's, you'll get all of them. He also doesn't miss as much time as most catchers because he frequently plays 1B on days when most catchers get off. Lee is a good player, but he's fairly streaky. Young is one of the most overrated players in fantasy. He has 15 HR power and 15 SB potential, at most. He'll give you a good BA and score a lot, but that's it. If you compare the players in the deal...

Rollins > Lee by a lot and

V-Mart > Young by a good amount.

Hope I helped!

Answer 4

reject that unfair trade

Answer 5

thats a tough one.  I might be inclined to stay with what I got because V. Mart only plays 5 days a week), but Rollins is tough to pass up.

Sorry, your on your own on this one.

Answer 6

you're better off with keeping lee and young

Answer 7

Lee is so hot right now and the other two aren't

Answer 8

I would decline catchers aren't valuable enough in fantasy league to get rid of for Lee and Young.