Should I accept the collectors money?

Question

A baseball card collector offered me $150 for my most rare cards. I know it's probably not a good deal. Can you tell me how much I should try an bargain him for.

in mint condition i have: entire 1985 red sox, a pedro martinez with piece of game jersey authentic, walter johnson, mike sweeney with piece of his jersey authentic

then for rare condition I have, a mickey mantle, and a mickey mantle with a piece of his jersey, a carl Yastrzecki with a piece of his bat authentic, rod carew, mer ott, 3 wade Boggs, and a Ted williams

Answer 1

No you should get more then $150

Answer 2

Buy a baseball beckett "price guide", see how much they are all worth, then decide whether or not it's worth the money hes giving you.

Answer 3

all of those cards for $150? Thats a scam. You need to find a professional or do some research online. That guy is a dirt bag trying to scam an unknowing person.

Answer 4

It doesn't sound like very much for what you may have.  The cards' value varies with the edition as well as the condition, but if I were you I would invest in a neutral evaluation process.  An up to date price guide or an independent service or something like that.  When you get the values, you can take a little less from the dealer, he has to make a profit on the transaction.  Plus it's the convenience of getting it done all at one time.

Answer 5

Buy a Beckett and look up the prices, that is the only way to tell how much they are really worth. Unless you to go a card shop and ask, but they aren't accurate a lot of times because they want to rip you off if you have good stuff. Look them up and then give him a fair price :)