Should I accept this offer?

Question

BJ Upton and Ryan Ludwick for Alexi Casilla and Matt Holliday.

I would get Upton/Ludwick.

My team right now:

C - Jorge Posada

1B - Jason Giambi

2B - Alexi Casilla

3B - Chipper Jones

SS - Hanley Ramirez

IF - James Loney

OF - Carlos Quentin

OF - Carlos Lee

OF - Matt Holliday

UT - Jay Bruce

UT - Ben Francisco

DL - Carlos Pena

SP - Brandon Webb

SP - Ryan Dempster

SP - Cole Hamels

RP - Trevor Hoffman

RP - Joakim Soria

RP - Mike Gonzalez

P - Justin Duchscherer

P - Josh Banks

P - Gavin Floyd

BN - Justin Masterson

Ideally, I was looking to acquire Garrett Atkins from the guy as well, in a 6 player deal, because I'm wary of Chipper at 3B with his injury-proneness.. but he countered with this.

Should I accept?

Answer 1

First of all nice team. YES, this is a great deal for you because Holliday and Ludwick are both batting above .300 so a pretty even deal, but Upton is playing better then Casilla he get you average and speed and some power. Do it.

Answer 2

Yes it is a great offer and upton is an amazing player.