Should I accept this trade? baseball.?

Question

I get:

Lance Berkman

Johan Santana

Justin Duchsherer

I lose:

Ian Kinsler

Miggy Cabrera

Dice-K

Aaron Cook

I need pitching having only Peavy along with players like Pettite, Campillo, Dice-k(In the trade), Scott Olsen

I dont need hitting much, but could use another outfielder like Berkman(1b and OF) to replace young. I was deep in pitching at the beginning of the season, but traded it away for hitting. I have Russel Martin, Tex, Kinsler(In trade),Chipper, Jose Reyes, Braun, Josh Hamilton, Delmon Young.

Answer 1

dont get red of Dice-K! or Miggy! Go Red Sox!

Answer 2

i dont think i would if i were you. you say you need pitching, but your giving up 1 great pitcher (Matsuzaka) and 1 good pitcher (Cook) for 1 great pitcher (Santana) and 1 great unproven risky pitcher (Duchscherer)

personally i think Santana is overrated, he is often a 1st round draft pick, and yet is only 8-7 with a 2.84 ERA.

Dice-K is 9-1 with the exact same ERA: 2.84. he has less Ks but he was on the DL so less opportunities.

in addition you are giving up a player who is quietly becoming the best player in the American League in Ian Kinsler.

Answer 3

No way.

Answer 4

ya i think that it is a good trade

if i were you i would take it

Answer 5

Yea, Definetly, Lance is solid, and Johan is Best after the first half of the season, I would quick get Johan before He turns electric in his next start! YES YES TAKE IT!

Answer 6

I'd take it..you gain the best hitter in baseball and two great pitchers when you only lose Kinsler and Dise-K..Miggy is overrated and Cook pitches for the Rockies so you never what you are getting there

Answer 7

maybe someday