Should I accept this trade in FFL?

Question

I get Eddgerain James and Clinton Portis; I give up Joseph Addain and Aman Green.

Answer 1

Yes. It depends on if you have another running back. James and  Portis will both be starters next year. Green won't be playing that much. I'd do it. Your getting 2 pro bowl running backs for 1

Answer 2

YEA

Answer 3

YES, BUT KEEP JENNINGS AT WR/RB

Answer 4

yes you should

Answer 5

It's not a bad deal for you.

Ahman Green will face some serious competition from Slaton in camp.  I think Slaton may win the job, or at least a lot of carries.

Addai is a complete stud, but you are still getting a first and second round caliber back in return... it's fair.

I don't love the deal, but it probably helps you.

This risk is in whether Portis thrives under Zorn's system, and who wins the QB job in Arizona.  Too early to tell...

Answer 6

you get a veteren powerback and an experienced all-around back for a young project back and a veteran back. i say yes, because portis is going to be the top player in this trade

Answer 7

I would not do that trade. Addai is by far the best back of the bunch. While Green isn't great, E. James is on the down side of his career and hasn't been putting up great numbers for the last couple years. Portis is good, but not as good as Addai.

With Addai and McGahee as your starters you will be fine.

Answer 8

I wouldn't do it either. Although Ahman Green is complete and total garbage anymore... it's not worth it to give up a young stud in Joseph Addai for two oldies in Portis and the Edge.

You have Addai and McGahee at RB, RB and Jennings at WR/RB... sounds like a good lineup just like that.