Should I accept this trade in a dynasty FFL?

Question

Dynasty meaning you keep the same team from year to year. The draft consists of just rookies (I see the top 4-6 being good prospects and the rest being hit or miss). I've been offered...

Thomas Jones & #17 overall pick

for

Eli Manning, #12 overall pick, Donald Driver

Here's my roster...

QB: Tony Romo, Eli Manning

RB: Ronnie Brown, Larry Johnson, Fred Taylor

WR: Santonio Holmes, Bernard Berrian, Donald Driver, Patrick Crayton

TE: Kellen Winslow, Vernon Davis

K: Mason Crosby, Neil Rackers

DEF: NYG, Carolina

Before the draft you have to shave your team down to 2 QB, 3 WR, 3 RB, tops. Scoring relies heavily on TD's

Answer 1

NOOO!! you have a *DIRTY* team and there is no way thomas jones and a 17th pick are even close to equal with eli, donald. and a 12th pick.  

Eli is a decent QB, and he is a great backup to romo.  driver is old and the QB situation is still up in the air in greenbay.  Driver is no good in the long run for your keeper league.  Thomas jones had a bad year last year adn he is playing for the jets who arent very good.  I hate to say it but you are getting ripped off with this trade if you do it

Answer 2

I believe that Thomas Jones will have a great season. 1500 yerds 12+ tds. All because hes running behind Alen Faneca, and Tody Richardson. Last year he did above average without them. This year, he ill do great with them. I have tried my damndest to get jones. i have him in 2 of my 3 leagues. he will be great this year.

Answer 3

lpllplp

Answer 4

Thomas Jones is expected to have a good season.  I would say about 1200 yards 6-7 Tds.  However, you have Ronnie Brown and Larry Johnson... you do not need Thomas Jones.  Each season, there will be some RBs from FA that will have breakout like Earnest Graham last year.  I believe that you can use Eli Manning/One of your TE to a team who needs help at QB/TE to upgrade your WR corp.  

Donald Driver does not have any trade value at all.  He cannot get any more than 5 tds.  Aaron Rodgers likes to throw to Greg Jennings... by watching him play against the Cowboys last season.  Donald Driver is also aging.  I believe that you can get somebody better from the Free Agent.. perhpas Sidney Rice or James Hardy (preferably Sidney Rice due to experience and Berrian on other side)

Good Luck.

Answer 5

I wouldn't, you lose depth at an already weak position for you (WR) for an RB who at this point would only be a bye week filler.  You need your higher draft pick to target a WR

Answer 6

i'd say no. you'd have to get rid of 2 players for one. sure Thomas is a #17, but Eli is a #12. Thomas isn't that much better then him.

Answer 7

I wouldn't.  You move down 5 spots in a draft with questionable depth...Jones doesnt really improve your already strong RB corps....and Driver is probably going to be your #1 or maybe #2 receiver.

Answer 8

dont do it. try to get a better draft pick from the other guy