Should I accept this trade in fantasy football?

Question

In my fantasy football league another guy requested a trade with my team. I have:

Plaxico Burress

Clinton Portis

Dallas Clark

He has:

Kevin Curtis

Edgerrin James

Tony Gonzalez

Should I accept the trade and get rid of Plaxico, Clinton, and Dallas Clark and receive Kevin Curtis, Edge, and Tony?

Right now I'm leaning towards keeping Plaxico, Clinton, and Dallas Clark, but I need advice.

Answer 1

all three of your players are really good so i wouldnt do it

Answer 2

no way

Answer 3

Keep the players you have as they have much more value.

Answer 4

Listen to your gut.  Avoid that trade like the plague...JUST SAY h**l NO!

Answer 5

No, you definitely should not do this trade.

Burress > Curtis

Portis > James

and surprise!  Clark > Gonzalez

This trade hurts you in all three positions there is no way I'd do it.

Answer 6

I think i'd keep it, and i can't believe you still go on Yahoo! Answers, haha. This is the first time i've been on it in like a year. Whatever, I'd keep them. Edge is older and not as good, and i've never even heard of Curtis. Gonzalez is good, but so is Burress and Portis.

My advice... KEEP THEM.

Answer 7

DO NOT MAKE THIS TRADE.  This would be a terrible deal for you.  Edge is unfortunately on the wrong team for his fading talent.  Curtis is good, but his production was scattered last season, no consistency.  Tony G is going to be a stud like usual, but Dallas Clark isnt a bad substitute in a pass first offense.  

Your guys are good man, Portis will be a stud this year, possibly top 5, def top 10.  Plax is a good red-zone threat, and Clark is good like I said.

Keeps your peeps

Answer 8

The season is two months away! What if someone breaks a leg in training camp. Slow down cowboy and at least wait for the games to begin.

Answer 9

No. Palaxico is solid if he stays healthy, same with Portis. If they stay healthy, they will have big years. Dallas Clark is still young and will perform.