Should I deal Marion Barber and Anthony Gonzalez for Maurice Jones-Drew and Plaxico Burress?

Question

My other RB is Jamal Lewis, my receivers are Colston, Brandon Marshall, and Nate Burleson. Don't you think a team of Lewis, MJD, Plax, Marshall, and Colston will be nice?

Answer 1

depends.  what are your other WRs/ RBs?    If you are set at WR then I would say no.  Gonzo is a sleeper and Barber is a stud.    If you have no WRs and are sitting on portis and lynch, then think about it.

without knowing anything else about your team though i'd say no

Answer 2

dude if you get those players you will rock plax is going to rock again this year and MJD is going to be better and sense you have jamal lewis you  will rock

Answer 3

i would, plaxico more tds and mjd could have breakout year

Answer 4

Is your league PPR?...

If so, it might be an OK trade.

But I don't see Marion Barber splitting too much time with Felix Jones, and even so, he's the power running back used in red zones.

Plaxico, again, is hurting and probably will be hurt again.

Answer 5

Absolutely not.  Barber will be a beast this year and in the top 6 off of the board.  He and Lewis are a great combo.