Should I do this fantasy baseball trade???

Question

I get:

BJ Upton 2B/OF TB

Aramis Ramirez 3B CHC

I give up:

Edinson Volquez SP CIN

George Sherrill RP BAL

Adrian Beltre 3B SEA

12 team mixed league. I'm decent with pitching

SPs

Zambrano

Kazmir

Burnett

Parra

Randy Johnson

Wainright

RPs

Lidge

Wood

Marmol

Broxton

R. Soriano (atl)

And I've been getting killed in TB and RBI, so the boost I'll get from Upton and Ramirez should be enough to get me a few offensive category wins, while I stay competitive in Ws, SVs, ERA & WHIP.

Answer 1

I would definitely do it.

Answer 2

Selling high on Volquez is a good idea because he has shown signs of earing down. Sherrill is great for saves and Ks but his ERA/WHIP aren't good for a closer. Beltre is a mutt so getting A-Ram would be a huge upgrade at 3rd plus you get a solid young player in Upton.

You've got pitching to spare so I'd make the trade.

Answer 3

Don't do it, Volquez is having a Cy Young kind of year, George Sherill is second in AL in saves and Adrian Beltre is having a decent year and has been the Mariners best player(although that is not saying much).

Answer 4

Pull the trigger on this deal.

Answer 5

yea i'd do it if i were you

Answer 6

I would definitely pull the trigger on that one.  There is a good chance that Sherrill could be a set up man in the near future if he gets traded.

Answer 7

its a tough decision Edison volquez is absolutely amazing and adrian beltre is alright, but i dont think sherril will hurt you any, especially with the pitching youve got. and you will get two great players in upton and ramirez. id do it