Should I do this trade for Lincecum?

Question

In this trade I get Tim Lincecum and he gets Francisco Liriano. Should I do it because I'm kind of confused on why he would offer this.

Thanks

Answer 1

yeah, i would lincecum is haveing a great season... your not sure if liriano will be a flash in the pan. take the safe proven vet

Answer 2

go for lincecum, he has proven that he can get wins even without run support this whole year so not that much will change in the future, except for the better

Answer 3

Do it.  I guess the guy think Liriano will be the pitcher he was two years ago without any hiccups.  I think Liriano will be great too, but Lincecum is a safer bet, plus I would take his numbers any day of the week.  Next year these two will be the one and two pitchers taken in a draft

Answer 4

Yes, Lincecum is haveing a great year. Liriano is just coming back from the minors so it might take a while for him to get back in a groove. But yes, accept this trade.