Should I drop David Garrard or Jay Cutler for Matt Schaub?

Question

Should I drop David Garrard or Jay Cutler for Matt Schaub?

Answer 1

Keep Garrard and drop Cutler.  Schaub could have a breakout season this year so I think it's a good choice if you pick him up.  Garrard threw like 3 interceptions last year so you don't have to worry about him turning the ball over.  He seems to be getting better every season and I think he'll have a huge year.

Answer 2

Why do you want Schaub?  Both are way better QBs than Matt.  Unless both have the same bye weeks.  I'm a Jay Cutler fan, but both are equal in talent.  I say keep them both, even if they share the same bye week.

Answer 3

If you can afford the bench space, keep them all until you can see how Schaub does.  If you have to drop, I would keep Garrard and Cutler based on experience.

Answer 4

keep cutler...  i dont think I would even drop garrard for schaub.

But if you really want schaub, then grop garrard

Answer 5

Even though I expect an above average year for Schuab, No. I believe Cutler and Garrard will both have solid years