Should I keep Kevin Kouzmanoff or Alexi Casilla?

Question

I already have 2 3rd basemans and 2 2nd basemans so their position does not matter. Which ever one I keep, will be a bench player.

Answer 1

Alexi looks good now but he has less experience and is more likely to fade in the long run. Go with Kouzmanoff.

Answer 2

Casilla has more upside and is on a better team in a better hitters park.  Kouz is a good D player but his bat lacks and is in a horrible offensive ball park.  Last time I checked D doesn't count in 5x5 Roto, so go with Casilla.