Should I make this trade, my players Jacoby Ellisbury and Ryan Ludwick for his: Carlos Gomez and Jason Giambi?

Question

What do yu think. Could you break this down for me? Thanks so much!

Answer 1

Absolutely not, Ellsbury is the best player in this deal and wins a category by himself every week(stolen bases). None of the other guys can say that. Giambi will slump soon and Gomez is not worth Ellsbury. I wouldnt trade Ellsbury unless your getting an all-star, which is what he is!

Answer 2

Nooooooo!

I recently dropped C.Gomez because his stolen bases/runs have slowed to a drizzle...I think he is on a much tighter leash

because he was being thrown out ALOT.Giambi is not better then Ludwick,either.~~~~~~~Good Luck!