Should I make this trade? fantasy football?

Question

i have:

Brady, Tom QB NE

Addai, Joseph RB IND

Portis, Clinton RB WAS

Holt, Torry WR STL

White, Roddy WR ATL

Williams, Roy WR DET

Gates, Antonio TE SD

Graham, Shayne K CIN

Ravens, DST

Roethlisberger, Ben QB

Forte, Matt RB

Turner, Michael RB

Young, Selvin RB

Buccaneers, DST

this guy offered me: David Garrard, Deuce McAllister, Steve Smith and Andre Johnson

for (my players): Ben Roliethsberger, Matt Forte, Torry Holt, and Roy Williams.

should i make this trade? considering the fact i need wide receiver help? or should i just stay put

???? thankss

Answer 1

yep, it's a good deal. you'll probably drop deuce immediately, but it's still a good deal for you.

Answer 2

this is tough, i say don't do it because Big Ben should have better season because of his WR's, Forte might start and will probaly see more carries then Deuce, Holt is so consistant, this is why the trade is hard, but Steve Smith has games where he will just go off, your call there.

then Andre Johnson and Roy, Andre is great, and better than Roy if he stays healthy.

Answer 3

I would take the trade as well.  Its a receiver upgrade and you will never start big ben as long as you have brady, and brady never misses a start so might as well get rid of ben for the WR help.  Forte and Deuce are irrelevant since chicago is bound to sign another RB soon...travis henry or kevin jones...

Answer 4

I would do it.  You will be giving up Big Ben and Forte, who won't be starting for your team.  They are probably better fantasy wise than Garrard and Duce but you aren't starting them so no biggie.  You get a pretty big upgrade at WR though.  Smith and A.Johnson are both top 5 WRs  Holt is past his prime and Williams will be competing with C.Johnson for passes now.

So...I would take it if I were ya.

Answer 5

I would try to rearrange the trade a little and not take deuce. You are set with a good running back in both Portis and Addai and dont need another. David Garrard came off a good season completing a great deal of passes without throwing an interception so that is a plus. Overall i think it is a good trade and i would take it .