Should I make this trade in fantasy baseball?

Question

I receive Carlos Quentin, But i give up David Dejesus and Salomon Torres. I need HRs and Stolen bases. Also I have three other closers (Franklin, Kobayashi, Mike Gonzalez). Should I do this?

Answer 1

Doesnt matter.  Your team stinks no matter how you slice it.  You didnt name a decent player in the whole bunch.

Answer 2

This would be an ok deal only if you aren't hoping to accumulate a lot of saves with your other closers.  Those 3 closers only have 6 more combined saves than Torres does himself.  Considering Isringhausen is back in the mix, Franklin's closing opportunities could take a hit, and he makes up 14 of the 23 saves of your 3 other closers.  However, Quentin has had a great year so far with 23 homers, but only has 5 stolen bases.  Dejesus has 100 hits, 10 homers and 9 stolen bases and is batting over .300.  You are probably better off keeping your players and looking for someone who steals a lot on the waiver wire.

Answer 3

Great answer number one.

Answer 4

Do it. Now. Before the other owner realizes what an idiot he is. DeJesus and Torres aren't even on a team in my 10 team league. Quentin is a top outfielder.